Keeler’s Neighborhood Steakhouse - Carefree, Arizona

Maureen T.

We all went for Mother's Day brunch. Our waitress came to our table right away, bringing water and whatever else we liked. By the way, their iced tea is very good. The food was delicious. You could order omelets from your table, if wanted. Breakfast buffet choices were scrambled eggs, roasted potatoes, green beans, asparagus, and sliced prime rib. Also, a crustacean center of shrimp, lobster, and oysters.
Desserts were fantastic. Needless to say, we thoroughly enjoyed our meal.

Paul C.

Very pleasant dining experience, solid service and atmosphere. We like the feel of the location.

Food was mixed-spinach dip, tomato and mozzarella salad excellent appetizers, filet and baby back ribs excellent main plates;
Asparagus an excellent side. Really enjoyed the ribs!

The NY strip and the Prime Rib were more “OK..”

So, mixed on the menu. Overall an enjoyable evening!

Marc R.

Jules our server was wonderful. Seated on the patio right by the country western singer guitarist. My sea bass sandwich was a good portion but no sauce or preparation to enhance the flavor. Came with truffle fries, though the amount of truffle oil wasn't noticeable to me. I have had tastier truffle fries elsewhere. The cheeseburger was large and popular with other diners. Had the stout beer which was good 👍

Diana B.

Friendly staff delicious food n great view. Great Happy Hour $$ on drinks n food. Sliders are good n very filling. Jen at the bar was great. Ashley is also fun -nice relaxing time. Roof top is open Wed - Sun after 5 pm. Fun relaxing great food n drinks.

Jeffrey M.

My overall experience was pleasant. The food was wonderful and service and atmosphere matched. With one exception. The lady behind the bar upsold me on a tomahawk steak. I would have hoped telling her I had never had one, she should assume I have no idea what they cost. Since it was not on the menu, the cost should have been disclosed. I guessed that it would be maybe double the highest priced steak. And I was misstaken. Triple the cost, $180 was a bit extreme for me. Now that is not to say it was not satisfactory,it was quite good, but not that good. So my advice is to be aware of what your ordering. I felt taken advantage of.

Patricia R.

Absolutely wonderful dining experience!! We were seated immediately with reservation and they even accommodated our table due to the unexpected chilly evening. Service excellent, Sea bass, steaks, Salmon, wedge salad were all delicious. Wonderful evening with our friends

Julene L.

WOW service at its finest!
We arrived at 5pm without reservations! Thinking we could sit at the bar, it was all full. The hostess made a extra effort to find us somewhere to sit! Lucky us they had a 5pm no show reservation outside on the porch one of the best tables ! And they found us and gave us the table. THEN we had Jacob to wait on us he was a true exceptional waiter, they had staff everywhere and was amazing.
Now the food! We had tenderloins the were BEAUTIFUL! 2in thick and perfectly done!
You get two sides I had scalloped potatoes which were decedent. I am an excellent steak home cook and this restaurant is the Best Steak house I have maybe ever eaten at and I have had dinner at some of the finest !
I will drive the 2 hours to return!!! SOON I hope
THANK YOU ALL

Todd K.

Thank you Sean! My brother and I sat at the bar with Sean and he was amazing! We can be a handful sometimes and even though we were having a very heated family “discussion”, Sean was a SuperStar! Thank you for understanding, and helping us in all the right ways! Hopefully they will let us return, lol…
Food was delicious, especially the Crispy Onion Rings, WoW! See you soon Sean, and as freshly minted CareFree residents, our presence will be often. Not Banned, as far as we know, YaY!