Alfie's Pizza - Lehighton, Pennsylvania

Malik A.

The pizza was actually good. I was very disappointed with the service. The cashier employee was very rude when taking the order and also when serving it. Not to mention that she will use the cashier and then directly take your pizza without wearing proper gloves.

Jason S.

I had a slice of the Sicilian and a new york style. Both were extremely tasty! The Sicilian had a crispy undercarriage, zero flop and every bite was delicious! The new york style had minimal flop and the amount of sauce and cheese complimented each other well. It's a gem of a place in Leighton and I will definitely be coming back for more!

Sicilian 8.1
New york 8.5

Ashley L.

Decided to grab some pizza & wings after the kiddo played football...
We ordered, sat down, good came rather quick.
The table was bumped & moved just a tad and ROACHES went scurrying everywhere.
Climbing up tables around us & got to the top of where our kid was sitting.

Disgusted, we left. Never again.. used to actually be a favorite of ours too.

Aaron C.

Quoted twenty minutes for a pickup order, one pie and a dozen wings. Twenty minutes later, arrived and waited another twenty-five minutes at the counter to get a floppy, flavorless, greasy pie and overcooked wings. While I waited, I asked for a refund and was given the runaround. Disappointing to say the least. In a town of a dozen pizza places, try elsewhere.

Anji B.

Love the handmade Taco Pizza. The staff was super awesome. Friendly Staff and Fast Service.

nancy D.

I placed an order for 2 pizzas along with hot wings and a soda. The delivery person brings 1 pizza and when I open the box, this is what I got. 😒 My family and I are the wings and 2 slices of the pizza. The cheese on the pizza was a bit rubbery and thick. So I called back and spoke to the counter person who said they would remake the pizzas. I said ok. Called back about 10 mins later and told them I don’t want the pizzas just give me a refund. Well the “manager” hung up on me twice, I heard her tell the counter person “I’m not talking to her.” They asked me for my number to have Leroy call me back. He calls me and tells me he will deliver the pizzas to me after I repeatedly said No I want a refund for at least 1 pizza. He then tells me “I owe you a pizza and hung up on me AGAIN! They are very unprofessional and I will not be ordering from them again! You do not treat people that way.

Tim K. J.

We went tubing at blue mountain for the day and grabed a hotel for the night and we were starving when we got back. So we tried a place the hotel recommend ALFIES PIZZA
136 S FIRST ST. LEHIGHTON PA. WE had a delivery to the hotel and it was super quick the food was delicious I would recommend the hotwings in a Medium sauce they were super delicious THE CHEESE STEAKS WERE VERY GOOD AS WELL. Fries were crispy we ordered 24 wings thinking we would have some left over for later and that didn't happen they were gone within two hours. SOILD SPOT FOR SURE. PLUS THEY DELIVER to country inn and suits..

La_jefa D.

They kno me here so when they seen this they looked me up on fb and did anything they could to make this up to me they truly r good ppl who care about their customers happiness … hoping this makes the difference will comment again next order

I’m a local I eat alfies a lot!! Since I moved here when I was 14!! And it used to be on point awesome food and awesome owners …. But the past couple years the quality has changed whoever they have new in there is not changing the oil in the fryer and giving out soggy/burnt fries so now multiple times this has happened and this ain’t even the worst it’s been but under my cheese and mixed in is always burnt nasty fries and they add way way way too much cheese on the pizza so it’s always soft on bottom and hard to eat! never used to have to ask for light cheese but now we always have to and it’s getting more and more disgusting anything fried we pick the edible shyt out and throw the rest away smh the owners of this local place are amazing but they need to kno their quality just ain’t it anymore!! stay away from fried foods and if you get cheese pizza ask for light cheese …personal cheesesteak Stromboli is amazing all time favorite def worth it!!! taco pizza is awesome as well!! it’s just anything deep fried and too heavy handed on the cheesing of the pizza 🍕 change your oil please 🙏