Fat Eddy's Bar-BQ - Grove City, Pennsylvania

Gilbert R.

Fat Eddy Fries are delicious, BBQ combo plate was outstanding, really good bbq sauce and baked beans. Don’t even get me started on the cornbread, it was to die for. Will definitely be back when I’m up this way.

Jon E.

First time here, but thoroughly enjoyed the burger and chips. Took an order of burnt ends home and they did not disappoint. Atmosphere was cool and chill but at lunchtime during the week, was not too busy which was nice. Will be back and highly recommend.

Ben S.

It's a good place to stop if you just spent the day at the Outlets. But let's get to it.

$70 dollars for 2 sandwiches with Mac and cheese as sides, plus one loaded fry app. The loaded fry was a really good starter. They pile on some pulled pork and cover it with bbq and cheese sauce. The brisket on the sandwiches was mid, and the mac & cheese lacked much flavor. I think the price demands the kitchen put out the best meat possible, it kinda fell short.

Overall, it's a 4/5. A good choice if you're out shopping all day and need to be revived for the car ride home.

Jenn G.

The place is spacious but feels rather industrial. The chicken was a bit dry but the bbq sauce fixed it, the brisket was ok and the Mac n cheese was great. The baked potato, however is not recommended. The cheese sauce is very artificial, the mix with the bbq sauce is unappetizing, and the potato itself was not yummy. Good service, much parking

Jen Z.

The resteraunt had a nice atmosphere. I ordered the Mac and cheese with brisket on top. The brisket was almost all fat. When I spoke to the waiter, he told me brisket is a fatty meat. While I understand that, it should never be all fat and no meat on most of the pieces. The picture is of just all the fat in my dish. To pay $8 for the brisket and that is what they put on top of my Mac and cheese is not okay.

Mitch M.

If you Love Brisket - Make a U turn and goto Primanti Bros. So you won’t be disappointed.
The Beans and Mac were Good.
The burnt end were a little splintery but acceptable. The brisket, Brisket had evidence of smoke and a tiny bit of bark but were un-redeemable. The sauce couldn’t save them. If I pulled this out of my smoker, I'd perform an exorcism and bury it in the backyard. Then fire my butcher. Maybe the chef had a bad night or cranked up the heat to finish the smoke quickly. Don’t know… There was a lot of food but the accountant will choke on the price for a lunch.

Matt D.

Ribs and pulled pork were both excellent! Weren’t were fall off the bone but they were very meaty done perfectly! Bbq sauce is excellent. Side fries and Mac and cheese were fantastic. Waitress was helpful and quick 10/10

Patricia F.

I've been coming to Grove City a couple times this year my daughter is going to college in slippery Rock. We are from Scranton Pa. I've been wanting to eat here every time I'm out that way. This time I just turned in I didn't ask anyone what they wanted.
We started with the fat Eddie's Fry's. I highly recommend these they can honestly be your meal. I first asked the server what kind of cheese was used for the Mac n cheese. She really didn't know just said smoked. So I'm guessing smoked cheddar or Gouda. I did order the Mac n cheese with brisket. She didn't ask what part of the brisket id like. Strange. The Mac n cheese really has no flavor it's just bland. The brisket is fatty lacking flavor also. The bbq sauce is delicious. I went back to eating the fries.
Atmosphere is really nice love the chalk wall and different signs they have hanging.